Thank you for agreeing to review a manuscript for The Journal of Education, Economic and Social Research (JEESR). Your contribution is vital to maintaining the quality of our publication. Please follow the guidelines below when reviewing:

1. Confidentiality

All review processes are confidential. Do not share, distribute, or discuss the manuscript with others outside the editorial team.

2. Objectivity and Constructive Feedback

Reviews should be objective, professional, and constructive. Please avoid personal criticism and provide suggestions for improvement.

3. Evaluation Criteria

Please assess the manuscript based on the following points:

• Originality: Does the work present new and significant findings?

• Relevance: Is the topic relevant to education, economics, or social research?

• Scientific Quality: Are the methodology, analysis, and conclusions appropriate and sound?

• Structure and Clarity: Is the manuscript well-organized and clearly written?

• References: Are the references adequate, current, and relevant?

4. Recommendation

You may choose one of the following recommendations:

• Accept without revisions

• Accept with minor revisions

• Revisions required

• Reject

Please justify your recommendation with clear reasons.

5. Conflict of Interest

If you have any conflict of interest or feel unqualified to review the manuscript, please notify the editor immediately.

6. Review Deadline

We appreciate your review within 2 weeks. If you need more time, kindly inform the editor as soon as possible.

Thank you for your valuable contribution to JEESR.